If you are looking for EIA UK, it's overhere.

Finding the Promise in Compromise: EIA Proposal to Jumpstart California HFC Reclaim

Last week EIA participated in California’s Air Resources Board (ARB) 6th workshop on proposed regulations to reduce emissions of super pollutant hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs) used in cooling. The state’s rigorous process for proposing new regulations on HFC refrigerants has been ongoing for several years now and is in the final stretch. Opportunities for stakeholder engagement have been abundant and ARB has invited input from industry along the way. They even aligned with an industry proposed 2023 deadline for transitioning new air conditioning equipment to refrigerants with a global warming potential (GWP) less than 750.

The same industry stakeholders that proposed 2023 as the deadline now claim that the date is unmeetable due to slower than expected updates to state building codes as well as economic hardships brought on by the COVID-19 pandemic. EIA, along with other environmental stakeholders, has stridently opposed any delay in proposed deadlines for these new regulations, which are already insufficient to meet the state’s 2030 emission reduction goals.

But, just maybe, this unforeseen situation presents an opportunity to actually increase emission reductions under the proposed regulation. ARB asked stakeholders to formulate alternate proposals that would allow companies requesting a delay to reduce an equal or greater amount of HFC emissions by 2030.

This is EIA’s proposal: What if there’s a way to provide manufacturers who need a short-term extension (2 years maximum) for relief, while in exchange requiring them to help jumpstart a market for increased use of recycled, or “reclaimed” HFC refrigerants? It's a fairly simple idea, and it just might work. Instead of buying new synthetically produced HFCs, equipment manufacturers can purchase “reclaimed” refrigerant” – that is, used refrigerant that’s undergone a cleaning process to remove impurities so it can be safely re-used without damaging equipment – to pre-fill new air conditioners or other equipment they sell onto the market in California.

Manufacturers will have to use enough reclaimed refrigerant to offset not just the initial refrigerant used to fill the equipment, but enough to also offset any additional refrigerant that gets added to replace leaked refrigerant over the equipment’s full lifetime. It’s not hard math; for most types of equipment we know estimated lifetime expectancy and how much refrigerant it leaks on average. This is information California already uses to estimate total HFC emissions for its greenhouse gas inventory.

EIA has long argued that we need policies both to transition new cooling equipment away from using HFCs, and also to manage existing HFCs by increasing collection, recycling, and sustainable disposal through destruction. Our report Search, Reuse, & Destroy: How states can lead on a 100 billion ton climate problem, provided recommendations for states to do just that. The biggest challenge to making this happen is that most refrigerant isn’t properly recovered from equipment at its end of life; it costs money and time to do so and there is no demand or value for its reuse. Instead most refrigerant gets vented into the atmosphere, a practice that’s illegal if done intentionally, but nonetheless commonly happens and contributes the vast majority of overall HFC emissions.

If equipment manufacturers were required, however, to begin bulk purchasing large quantities of reclaimed HFCs, it would create a market value for recovering and collecting used HFC refrigerants. This would ‘jumpstart’ a greater market for used refrigerant, one that could grow over time, particularly with other complimentary policies and incentives. This effect could actually increase the emission reductions achieved by the regulation before 2030.

We look forward to finding promise in compromise by continuing discussion on this idea for California, already a leader in HFC reduction policies, to blaze a new trail.

View all Blog Posts

Recent Blog Posts

Can I be HFC-free? A Quest for Climate-friendly Cooling
08/10/2020
Supermarkets in particular have enormous refrigeration systems that extend past the display cases to back room chillers, refrigerated trucks, cold warehouses and so on. With such large systems, supermarkets are among the largest corporate offenders of HFC use, with thousands of tons of these chemicals throughout their cold chain. Yet out of nearly 40,000 supermarkets in the U.S., barely 1% are known to have transitioned to HFC-free systems; our Supermarket Scorecard shows that action and change throughout the industry is needed. These large companies have a greater climate footprint than you or me, and thus a greater responsibility to transition to climate-friendly alternatives.
Unchartered Territory: Funding Climate Action During a Pandemic
07/16/2020
This week, Parties to the Montreal Protocol, renowned as the world’s most successful environmental treaty came together remotely for their annual intersessional meeting, known as the Open-ended Working Group (OEWG). The Montreal Protocol has a vital role to play in addressing climate change, as it becomes increasingly clear that we are currently not on the pathway to limit global temperature rise to below 1.5 °C.

Recent Reports

The Risk of Ozone-Depletion Persists - Comments to EPA
10/15/2020
EIA submitted comments to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) regarding the draft risk assessments of methylene chloride, carbon tetrachloride, and other priority chemicals undergoing risk evaluations under the Amended Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA).
EIA Briefing on the IEC Standards Proposal for Air Conditioning
10/08/2020
With global stock of household air conditioners (ACs) expected to triple by 2050, continued use of HFCs in ACs is fueling the climate crisis.

Recent Press Releases

100,000+ Consumers Say Walmart Should Not Put Off Curbing Climate-Harming Refrigerants for 20 Years
09/21/2020
New Announcement Waiting Until 2040 to Phase Out HFCs Leaves Walmart Way Behind Competitors – Including Aldi, Target, and Whole Foods – Who Already Have Taken Action
Unlocking Kigali Amendment Climate Benefits
08/17/2020
A new safety standard proposed by an International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) working group is vital to maximizing emission reductions from a global phase-down of super pollutant hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs)
What are the HFC-free Technologies?
Widespread adoption of HFC-free technologies is cost-effective, energy efficient, and climate-friendly. Read EIA’s report Putting the Freeze on HFCs for hundreds of examples of HFC-free technologies available and in use today.
A Global HFC Phase-down
The October 2016 Montreal Protocol meeting in Kigali, Rwanda yielded a global agreement to phase down HFCs. Now countries must ratify and implement the Kigali Amendment! Read and share EIA's briefing on this great opportunity and obligation to avert climate catastrophe.
Help us mitigate climate destroying gases
Where are HFCs used?
What are HFCs?
How to Recycle Your Fridge